By Stephen May
NEW PALTZ, N.Y. — Jervis McEntee (1828–1891), an artist of great sensitivity, intelligence and complexity, was a central figure in the Hudson River School. Although his work has been widely admired for years, he remains one of the least examined of this group of artists. This is in part because over the years so much attention has been paid to his close associations with other Hudson River School painters and as a fixture in the milieu of the storied Tenth Street Studio Building.
With laudable ambition, the Samuel Dorsky Museum of Art at the State University at New Paltz has organized “Jervis McEntee: Painter-Poet of the Hudson River School,” on view through December 13. Guest curator Lee A. Vedder, assisted by the Dorsky’s curator Daniel Belasco, assembled 80 paintings and oil sketches and a number of historical documents. The exhibition, says Sara J. Pasti, director of the Dorsky, “is the largest public presentation of McEntee’s art since his memorial exhibition in 1891 and is sure to secure McEntee’s place as an important figure in American art.”
McEntee was born in Roundout (now Kingston), N.Y., and little is known of his childhood. Yet, as Pasti observes, he was “truly shaped by the culture and landscape of the Hudson Valley.” In 1850, at age 22, McEntee exhibited his first painting at the prestigious National Academy of Design (NAD).
About the same time, McEntee apprenticed with Frederic Church, a successful figure in the American art world; they remained lifelong friends. It was an awkward relationship — Church was a commanding, self-important figure, gifted, outgoing, highly successful, a great self-promoter and committed to the nationalistic ideology of Manifest Destiny. McEntee, on the other hand, was an introspective persona and artist, and had a poetic, emotional temperament. As art historian J. Gray Sweeney has observed, “McEntee characteristically painted intimate scenes filled with nostalgia rather than panoramic visions of landscapes stretching to the horizon in magisterial gaze….”
Church and McEntee did agree with “the idea that art was the interpreter of nature; nature was the interpreter of God,” says Sweeney, adding that this “was the core belief … among the Hudson River School.” McEntee benefited from Church’s technical mastery of the oil sketch depicting landscape forms recorded directly in the field and then reworked in the studio. Church’s special gift for conveying dramatic atmospheric and light effects at twilight and sunset influenced his student in works like “Twilight.”
At the same time, McEntee was not one to “embrace Church’s penchant for large panoramic landscapes and grand atmospheric spectacle. Rather, quiet meditation on the autumn season and the thoughts and moods of a landscape interested [McEntee] more as a painter,” says curator Vedder.
Soon, McEntee took up the annual routine of New York professional landscape painters, spending fall and winter in his city studio and spring and summer at his home/studio in Roundout.
Following the Civil War, McEntee sought inspiration abroad, visiting the art capitals of London, Paris and Rome, which exposed him to contemporary European landscape styles that influenced his output in the 1870s and 1880s
In 1857, McEntee began a 30-year residency in the celebrated Tenth Street Studio Building, where he hobnobbed with some of America’s finest painters. He was particularly close to Hudson River School friend Sanford Gifford, as well as John Ferguson Weir, Worthington Whittredge and figurative painter Eastman Johnson. McEntee became a full NAD academician in 1861, and exhibited regularly there until 1890. He joined the right clubs, which became venues to showcase his art.
McEntee was a reluctant self-promoter, unsure that the public would like his paintings, and was only modestly successful in peddling his completed works. While he was beholden to the Hudson River School tradition, McEntee followed his own drummer and late in his career integrated European landscape styles — French Barbizon and Impressionism — into his work.
McEntee’s early autumnal landscape depictions are distinguished from his Hudson River School contemporaries by their cloudy skies, contemplative, melancholy mood and his emotive communion with what he called the “soberer phases of Nature.” While Jasper Cropsey and other Hudson River School artists emphasized the saturated oranges, reds and yellows that make New England’s fall foliage world famous, McEntee focused on the “graver moods” and more subtle transitions of color at season’s end, when faded leaves fall from trees.
“View Facing the Catskills,” a poetic landscape suffused with the red of late fall, epitomizes McEntee’s meditative paintings. Ditto “Mist Rising Near New Paltz,” in which deftly delineated fog adds a painterly touch that distanced McEntee from Hudson River School conventions. Critics dubbed it a melancholy composition.
“Some people call my landscapes gloomy and disagreeable,” McEntee wrote in his journal. “They say I paint the sorrowful side of nature… But that is a mistake… Nature is not sad to me but quiet, pensive, restful.”
Just as McEntee was gaining acceptance in the New York cultural establishment, the Civil War broke out. He briefly commanded a Union unit.
After the war, McEntee continued to explore sentimental autumn scenes, but in a more personal style that suggested Modernist interests. Standouts from this period include a dark study of a sinuous, gnarly “Old Birch, Kauterskill Clove” and a sun-splashed figure sitting on a rocky promontory in the foreground of a green field and forest and in the distance the steep incline of a mountain in “Summer Hills, Kauterskill Clove.”
McEntee and Gifford often went on sketching expeditions together to “enjoy the wild beauty of lovely lakes and mountains….” The resulting paintings were more optimistic and celebratory than his early work, filled with the naturalistic effects of light and atmosphere, such as an expansive view of Gifford seated on rocks near the summit of Cadillac Mountain on Maine’s Mount Desert.
McEntee and Gifford went abroad briefly in 1863, and for a year in 1868. McEntee’s visits to museums, galleries and studios acquainted him with various European Modernist trends, which influenced his later work.
In an unusual subject for the artist, for example, “The Danger Signal” shows a railway train stopped by a driving snow storm that has blown drifts across the tracks. Sweeney accurately sees the influence of British star J.M.W. Turner, whose hazy, vaporous paintings McEntee had seen in London.
McEntee bequeathed to posterity detailed journals covering the early 1870s until his death in 1891. They offer glimpses into the life of a Hudson River School painter during the Gilded Age, albeit one with personal and money problems. McEntee died lonely and unhappy.
In his eulogy, McEntee’s close friend Whittredge recalled his work as “born of his peculiar disposition, which was not gloomy, but tinged with a gentle melancholy. They were poems. No painter of the period stamped his individuality upon his work more strongly than did McEntee.”
The catalog, published by the Dorsky and distributed by SUNY Press, sells for $35.
The Dorsky is at 1 Hawk Drive on the campus of SUNY at New Paltz. For information, www.newpultz.edu or 845-257-3844.
Stephen May is an independent historian, writer and lecturer who divides his time between Washington, D.C., and midcoast Maine.